Both the Amazon Echo and Google Home have earned their place at the top of the smarthome hierarchy, but which one should you buy?Amazon opened the industry wide with the release of the echo in 2014 and has since become the company’s most popular hardware product. Since then, Google has been having fun with Google Home, a direct competitor to Echo who wants to get the upper hand. Here are some differences and similarities between these two home assistants.Experts Break Down The Difference Between Google Home and Amazon EchoThat’s no surprise, but when it comes to random questions about all sorts of facts Google Home can be at the top of the pack thanks to Google’s Knowledge Graph. That does not mean the Amazon Echo is completely stupid, but in our tests there were a handful of questions that Google Home could answer for, while Alexa simply replied, “Sorry, I do not know the answer to your question. ” For example, Alexa was not able to answer questions such as “What is the average age of a person?” (71 years, by the way), but Google Home was able to give me the answer right away. However, Alexa did a better job in some areas when I asked both devices, “In how many movies is Tom Hanks already?” Alexa was able to find the answer (83 films), while Google Home just mentioned. I only mentioned a few films that Hanks directed. Google Home can also remember the previous question, which is useful. So if you asked, “Who played Woody in Toy Story?”, Would Google Home say Tom Hanks, and then you could say, “How old is he?” Continue and Google Home would say his age, although you have not done it directly Tell “Tom Hanks”. Alexa is not able to do that. Google Home has slightly better physical controls Both the Echo and Google Home have a small handful of controls on the device that allow you to turn the volume up and down and mute the microphone. However, you can do a little more with the Google Home control interface. The echo contains buttons that allow you to increase or decrease the volume, mute the speaker, or enable and disable Alexa. That’s about it. On Google Home, the entire interface is a touchpad, and finger gestures are used to control everything, which is easy to understand. It lets you play or pause music, adjust the volume, and enable Google Home to start listening. However, the microphone mute switch is located on the back of the unit, which is a bit of an awful place for it. Overall, it really depends on what kind of controls you want to use – touchpad fans like the Google Home better, while tactile-keypad lovers like the echo. Amazon Echo Vs. Google Home Black Friday: Which Is Best?When Google Home first appeared, the full-size echo still cost $ 180, which allowed Google to undercut Amazon by $ 50 and pay the house $ 130. However, things are drastically more competitive now. The full-size echo is now only $ 100 (thanks to the second-generation release), while Google Home still stands at $ 130. However, both companies sell their smaller versions (Google Home Mini and Echo Dot) for $ 50. It will be interesting to see if Google will lower the home’s permanent price to $ 100 to match the full echo, but that’s obviously speculation for another day. Gift that is not: Amazon Echo Vs. Google Home There are many options for smart speakers out there, but two devices prevail: Amazon Echo and Google Home. But which one should you buy this Christmas? Echo and Home are similar in price, they have a similar number of iterations and they work just as well with your smart home. What makes you different? This article was written as a companion to Ian Morris’ play. He argues the opposite point – that Amazon Echo is better. These are honest opinions, but we agree not to vote.Gift This, Not That: Amazon Echo Vs. Google HomeThe sound quality is on the one hand an obvious difference. It’s better, much better on the echo. But for me that’s not the true value of these devices. What’s really important is how smart they are. Home is comfortable in this department. Why? Home seems to benefit massively from Google’s Knowledge Graph (which summarizes the search results for a simplified answer) and the overall strength of the Google search engine. This is the core of Google’s product offering: concise, “intelligent”, forward-looking information when and how you need it. In physical terms, this is called the “Assistant” and it controls all of Google’s products: the Pixel phone, the devastating headphones, and a range of third-party products that use it. Therefore, Google is investing time and effort in the development of the wizard, which will be displayed in Home. Embarrassing questions about train times, theater performances, tuning an instrument, flight bookings – and anything else that comes to mind – Assistant has an answer. However, Amazons Echo, which is powered by Microsoft’s Bing search engine, did not succeed. It struggles with questions about flight times and train times – if you’ve ever used Bing, you know why. Amazon has tried to mitigate this with its own Alexa skill store (or apps as they are known elsewhere) that effectively bridge the knowledge gap. The problem is that the process of calling the ability is tortuous and incoherent. You have to say the name of the ability to trigger it and ask for an answer in the right way. You’ll probably ask the same question more than once if you refine it to get the right answer, which is not exactly in the sense of a “smart” speaker. The Skill Store is full of dross. There are a lot of demoware and mostly useless skills. Google Home vs Amazon Echo – versions and priceWhile we look at the main speakers of Echo and Google Home in this article, it pays to think about how to set up your home for future use. Amazon has the largest selection of smart speakers. The Echo is the all-rounder that costs £ 90 compared to the original £ 150. If you want a smaller speaker, the tiny Echo Dot costs £ 50, making it cheap enough to fill your home. Its sound is not great if you want something for music, but you can use Bluetooth or the 3.5mm audio jack to connect it to a better set of speakers.Google Home vs Amazon Echo: Which is the best smart speaker?For smart home enthusiasts, there’s the new Echo Plus (£ 140), which features a built-in Zigbee hub to control devices like Philips Hue lamps. It’s a great idea in theory, but it’s not quite ready for primetime. Then there’s the Echo Show (£ 200), which adds a touchscreen to the echo, so you can interact with the wizard in a completely different way and display visual content, such as the feed from a surveillance camera. Google only has two products. The Original Home is the main product that rivals the Echo in terms of features and price (£ 89). Then there’s the newer Google Home Mini (£ 50), which competes with the Echo Dot and is cheap enough to put it in your home. This product has no audio outputs, so you can not easily connect it to an external hi-fi system (well, not without this handy Google Home 3.5mm Audio Jack hack that is). Google currently has no language assistant with a built-in screen. Google Home vs Amazon Echo – DesignBoth Amazon Echo and Google Home are voice-activated speakers that you can yell at without your hands. While Google won the design battle, the second-generation Amazon Echo is rising. While the first echo looked a bit simple and industrial, Amazon made the new smart speaker much more attractive, and there are now a choice of six finishes: three materials, two woods and a metallic choice. This makes it much easier to find the product that fits your home decor. The Google Home remains a good eye-catcher. It has a curvier shape that, according to Google, is inspired by wine glasses and candles. The lower case can be exchanged for different trays that fit your decor – there are six trays available in fabric or metal. It has a sloped top, with four LEDs to give visual feedback. Google Home vs Amazon Echo – Voice AssistantThe Amazon Echo contains Alexa’s digital assistant, while Google Home is loaded with the imaginary Google Assistant. Alexa is capable of understanding simple commands or even a series of simple commands, but they’re pretty simple. And the default search engine is Bing. Alexa also requires that you formulate things in a certain way so that she understands you, and the language you have to use is not always natural. Amazon’s other problem is that it’s a wake-up word (Alexa, by default, but you can choose Echo, Amazon, or Computer), which means the voice assistant often wakes up by misunderstanding what you’ve said. In contrast, Google Assistant has the distinct advantage of Google. That’s why Assistant not only has a wealth of information – it’s built into Google’s entire architecture. Share your shopping list with Google Home, and the wizard can later reproduce it on your Pixel phone. And with a two-word wake-up formulation, Google Home is less self-explanatory. Amazon Echo vs. Google Home: Which Voice Controlled Speaker Is Best for You? Google Assistant also provides a bidirectional conversation based on Google’s native natural language processing algorithm. The wizard is context-aware, so the conversation should be more natural and less like a list of stilted commands. For example, you can say, “What’s the weather tomorrow?” To get a prediction. Follow up with “And tomorrow,” and Google knows that you’re following a follow-up weather report. Google’s powerful features let you request directions or traffic alerts at any time. The results are retrieved from Google Maps. In comparison, the echo can only give you traffic information to an address that you enter into the Alexa app. That does not mean that Google wins everything hands-down, since Alexa can do some things Google can not. For example, Alexa can retrieve information from a G Suite Google Calendar (which is a paid account), while Google Assistant still can not. And if Alexa can not do something, there’s an app store full of skills that you can use to extend capabilities beyond what Google Home can do. There’s everything from tube status updates to bedtime stories in the mix.Google Home vs Amazon EchoIf you are interested in smart home controllers or frequently use Amazon Prime, Amazon’s Alexa platform is the best option for your home. Among the Alexa-enabled speakers, the category-defining Amazon Echo is the best. We prefer the second-generation echo to Google Home for its rich features, comprehensive support for smart home devices, the ability to play the most popular music streaming services, and superior sound quality. In addition to the built-in features, the Alexa platform includes a growing list of “skills” (more than 15,000 at the last count), comparable to apps on a smartphone, features such as reading recipes, ordering pizza, or calling one About. Not all abilities are useful, but the echo still does much more than the Google Home. The Echo is not the all-capable Star Trek computer, but it’s an intelligent digital assistant that is constantly improving as Amazon adds more abilities. In addition to the standard Echo model, Amazon offers several other Alexa-enabled smart speakers: the smaller Echo Dot, which is a good choice if you want to connect it to your own (higher-end) speaker system; the Echo Plus with built-in Zigbee Smart Home Hub; the portable echo tap; and the video-ready Echo Show, along with the smaller echo spot and the fashionable echo look. There are also some third-party options, including Anchor’s Sonos One and Eufy Genie. Google Home takes advantage of Google’s search and voice control know-how (and the ability to link multiple Google accounts so you can view your calendar for each day, set and manage reminders in Keep, and report traffic conditions along the way Use of card data). If you use it with more than one account, the Home can even distinguish users by the sound of their voice. But the “Google” part of Google Home is not as powerful as we would like. It generally provides more detailed answers than Alexa, but is not significantly better able to perform simple tasks in daily life. For example, adding events to your Google Calendar is unnecessarily embarrassing. And although there are smart home integrations and “third party” actions similar to those of Alexa, it has less than Alexa, although Google Home understands two commands at the same time as of November 2017. The undeniable advantage of Home is its ability to serve as a controller for a Chromecast Audio Multiroom audio system. This means that you can use voice commands to send the same song or podcast to multiple synchronized speakers in different rooms at the same time. While Alexa has recently added similar features, Chromecast still offers more options and a better track record. Google Home vs Amazon Echo DESIGNGoogle has done a great job of designing Home to fit any environment. It is a relatively compact unit that is only 142.8 mm high and weighs 477 g. It has an angled, white, matte upper plastic half and a colored mesh underside that hides the speaker. Fabric bases are available in mango, navy and violet as well as metal bases in carbon, copper and snow. This ability to customize the design has also been echoed for the second generation, for which you are plump for fabric, metal effect and wood options. The new Amazon Echo is much better than the original, with a less industrial look and a shorter cylindrical design. Amazon has replaced the volume ring at the top with dedicated louder and quieter volume keys, more in line with the Google Home Mini design. Google Home itself has a touch-sensitive interface on which you can use your finger to draw a circular motion to adjust the volume. The Amazon Echo features seven small holes, each featuring a separate beam-forming and noise-canceling microphone. In comparison, Google Home only has two microphones, which should mean that the echo will better accommodate your instructions in a noisy environment. In practice, Google Home only has problems when streaming audio at maximum volume.Google Home vs Amazon Echo SOUND QUALITYWhile many aspects of the new echo have been improved, the new 2.5-inch speaker and the small tweeter actually offer a poorer sound quality than the original. It’s not that crisp and lacks the bass, which is good for podcasts and news briefings, but the difference is remarkable when audio is streamed. Google Home has a 2-inch driver and two 2-inch passive emitters by comparison. It’s pretty powerful and offers good audio quality for what it is, but is best placed as a kitchen radio. Both devices are connected to music subscriptions – Google Home supports Google Play Music and Spotify (including the free version), while Echo offers Amazon Music and Spotify. And you can stream live radio over TuneIn.WHAT CAN GOOGLE HOME AND AMAZON DO ECHO?Google Home and Amazon Echo do the same when it comes to answering your questions, controlling your smart home technology, and streaming audio. But Google Assistant is the much wiser of the two, enabling more natural conversation threads and understanding most of the questions you might want to ask. In comparison, Echo’s Alexa will often tell you that she does not know that. Google also has the great advantage of its existing ecosystem: Gmail, Calendar, Maps, Android and other services. After signing in to your Google Account, you may be able to For example, add medical appointments to a specific calendar, check traffic on the way to work, and find out what meetings you have that day. Google Home can also talk to other Google gadgets like Chromecast, Chromecast Audio, and other speakers like Google and Sony. If you’re using a Chromecast, you can say to Google Home, “Show me pictures of my vacation in Spain.” Google Photos will be displayed and displayed on your TV. You can also ask for a specific video from YouTube or a broadcast on Netflix.Like Amazon Fire tablets, you will not find any Google services on the Echo. Amazon takes the lead in integrating services and your existing smart home kit. It’s usually possible to connect services to Google Home through third-party IFTTT if that integration is not already set up. However, the fact that the echo has been in place since 2014 means that developers have spent a lot of time creating their apps and hardware working with Alexa. Alexa has an extensive collection of these integrations, known as Skills, that are broadly useful. However, we can not help believing that a large number of these skills are things you’ll never use – such as the ability to make animal noises – and it’s annoying to add every ability and then keep the exact command. Google Home often answers these questions without configuration and without phrasing.