Health Article Review

The article “Study: Obesity Surgery Can Cure Diabetes” by Carla Johnson provides in-depth analysis of the argument that diabetes can be cured by the obesity surgery. It is claimed that patients who have undergone obesity surgery are more likely to cure diabetes within the next two years, whereas patients who prefers standard illness treatment are less likely to be cured.

After surgery patients had no necessity to take diabetes drug as their blood tests appeared to be normal. Therefore, the article addresses community of people suffering from diabetes and obesity, and the primary health concern is how to make treatment methods more effective and less exhaustive. (Johnson, 15)

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

Stomach band procedure is less widespread in the United States than in Australia. Many Australian doctors claim that gastric bypass is one of the most effective ways of diabetes treatment and prevention because it is possible to achieve remission within the next several months or even days.

Usually, diabetes was considered a chronic and progressive disease, but band surgery offers real hope for al patients. However, one of the limitations of treatment is that it can be applied only to obese patients with diabetes, but doctors are going to continue researches to see the benefits of the method.

Diabetes experts recommend to weight side effects and the long-turn perspective of illness relapse.  Surgery is less likely to become appropriate for diabetes patients with normal weight and, moreover, surgery to obese patients is restricted by the current federal guidelines. (Johnson, 15)

The positive moment is that research study (55 patients involved) was initiated to compare diabetes recession patients who are subjected to surgery and standard drug care. That study appeared to be the highest-quality evidence that method does work. In two years more than 20 patients showed recession in diabetes.

Dr. Schauer says that “few studies really qualify as being a landmark study. This one is. This opens an entirely new way of thinking about diabetes”. (Johnson, 15) This study provided strong foundation for further researches.

Researchers claim that obesity is dangerous factor for diabetes patients. Patricia Anderson in her article “Obesity: Trends and Potential Cause” argues that obesity leads to pediatric hypertension, diabetes mellitus; it increases the risk to become ill with coronary heart disease.

(Anderson, 22) Further, Diez in the study of “Obesity: Susceptibility, cause, and management” says that the rates of obesity during last thirty years have significantly increased compared with rates till 1970. Therefore, the more obese people the more possibilities of increased diabetes rates. (Diez, 678) Australian doctors assume that to decrease diabetes rates it is required to decrease obesity among children and adolescents.

The author of the article supports such idea claiming that “what’s known is that excess fat can cause the body’s normal response to insulin to go haywire”. Analysts say that “there are numerous factors contributing to this worrying phenomenon, ranging from children’s increasingly sedentary lifestyles, the Americanization of the traditional southern European diet, and a decline in physical education in public schools”. (Anderson 2006)

If not to address the problem of obesity, the result will be rather serious health and social consequences in future life. For example, obese people may undergo discrimination, lower self-esteem and fewer opportunities for self-expression. Moreover, obese people have more health problems than people with normal weight.

To control the rise in obesity it is needed to implement prevention programs and actually to understand better the necessity of obesity treatment. Australian doctors say that patients who have lost weight have more chances to eliminate diabetes.

As to America, more than 1000,000 surgeries is performed each year and the American diabetes Association seems to be very interested in Australian findings. Dr. Buse, the University of North Carolina School of Medicine in Chapel Hill, says that “there is a growing body of evidence that bariatric surgery is an effective tool for managing diabetes”. (Johnson, 16) American doctors are interested in the effectiveness of surgery in obese patients; however, they realize that not all issues are clear.


Anderson, Patricia. (2006). Obesity: Trends and Potential Causes. The Future of Children, 16, 1, 19-27.

Diez, W. (1983). Obesity: Susceptibility, Cause, and Management. Journal of Pediatrics, 103, 5, 676-686.

Johnson, Carla. (2008). Study: Obesity Surgery Can Cure Diabetes. The Journal of American Medical Association, 299, 4, 15-16. Retrieved February 3, 2008, from